How to Choose the Best Crib Mattress?
Table of Contents
Top Best Crib Mattresses Based on Reviews and Price
How to Choose a Good Crib Mattress?
Choosing a crib mattress might appear like a straightforward job. You just go to the nearest store that sells crib mattresses and demand for the best one. Then some ask Google to show them the best crib mattress.
However, even in an ideal world where both salespeople and our favorite search engine are honest, selecting the best one can be tricky as there is a lot to consider. Plus, there is each person’s understanding of what’s best.
To make things easier, here is a set of considerations that can help you make the best possible choice.
16 Essential Factors to Consider Before Choosing a Crib Mattress
1. Consider the Type of Mattresses
There are two types of crib mattresses – foam and innerspring. Generally speaking, both types can provide excellent support and will keep your little one at peace. Most foam mattresses are made of polyethylene and are quite light. Plus, the best ones are made from orthopedic firm foam. On the other hand, innerspring mattresses can be made of various layers. The number of layers of the and the material of those layers determines their level of comfort and price.
Pro tip: When buying a mattress with innerspring, always look for those with border rods.
2. Is It Convertible?
If you consider turning your baby crib into a toddler bed, you might want to go with dual-firmness convertible mattresses. The special thing is that on the one side they are cushier for the toddlers, while on the other side, they tend to be extra-firm.
In any case, it is best to place this consideration in the “non-essential” category. There is a pretty good chance that the baby will be quite content with a firm mattress when she/he becomes a toddler.
Pro tip: If you decide to go with a dual-firmness mattress, don’t flip it too soon.
3. Let’s Go Organic
If you are the type of parent that cares about eco-friendly products, or you are simply concerned about the various chemicals used in the manufacturing process, look for crib mattresses that have a label saying “organic” or “natural.”
But, know that there are no recognized standards for this claim. Thing is “organic” might only refer to the organic cotton used for the covering.
The same remarks also apply for crib mattresses labeled as eco-friendly.
The truth is, if you want to know about the materials used for making the crib, you need to ask questions. That is the only way to learn how eco-friendly or organic are some crib mattresses.
4. Consider the Fit
There is an actual law that says full-sized mattresses need to be up to 6 inches thick and must be at least 7 1/4 inches by 51 5/8 inches. Another way to check this out is if you walk into a store that sells crib mattresses, and check that by putting one inside one of the cribs there.
Pro tip: Determine whether the mattress is fit by trying to squeeze more than two fingers. If you can squeeze three or more fingers, then the mattress is too small.
5. Is It Machine-washable?
One of the easiest things to predict is that kids tend to soil their crib mattress more often than their parents like them. At the same time, it is good to know that diapers are not entirely efficient, and sometimes leaks happen.
A removable and machine washable exterior cover can save you a lot of time. Furthermore, machine washable textiles are proven to last more than the ones that can be washed only by hand.
6. Material Breathability
Firmness and comfort matter a lot when choosing a crib mattress, but breathability is also super outstanding. Breathability in crib mattresses refers to the proper vents that allow better air circulation. Their purpose is to stop the accumulation of odor while making the small feel as comfortable as possible.
Pro tip: The best ones will make the mattress smell quite fresh even after months of use, regardless of how often it was soiled by the little one.
7. Consider the Firmness Index and Sturdy Covering
Extreme softness can expose the little one to accidental SIDS and other hazards. The best way to check that is by applying pressure to it with your hand. If it is a good mattress, it will need not more than a few seconds to recover. Anything more than that, it means simply move on to the next one and forget about that one.
On average, babies spend around 75% of their time in their cribs. Because of that, their coverage needs to be both sturdy and waterproof. These mattresses ensure greater resilience to wear and tear, as well as from soggy diapers.
8. Certified Padding
To make sure that your baby has the best possible crib mattress, make sure that it bears the mark of CPSC. If the mattress has this mark, it means that it has been inspected and certified by the American Society for Testing and Materials.
9. Consider Weight With Firmness
If the crib mattress is too heavy, then you can’t change its sheets singlehandedly. On average, infants need a change of bedding once or twice every week.
If the mattress is heavier than 7 kilograms, changing the infant’s bedding will feel quite the task.
The issue with ultralight or thin mattresses is that their recovery rates are really poor. They are less durable, and all in all, they are of low quality.
Ideally, the mattress should weigh from three to seven kilograms.
10. Don’t Stress Out About Warranties
When it comes to many other products, having a warranty can go a long way. Sometimes, even extending that warranty on top of its original warranty period can make sense.
However, when it comes to crib mattress warranty, don’t put much fate into it. Some brands offer warranties for one, two, three, six years, or even a lifetime warranty.
The fair thing to say is that warranties for crib mattresses are more of a marketing trick, rather than something more.
11. Consider Density
The denser the mattress is, the better. To check this, grab both sides of the mattress with both hands and press hard. If you can’t press to deep, then you’ve got a pretty dense mattress in your hand.
12. Recommendations From APP
This is not one thing but a set of guidelines determined by the American Academy of Pediatrics. Their guidelines for SIDS Reduction and Sleep Safety are regularly updated and will advise you on which features matter most when choosing a crib mattress.
13. The Shape of the Crib
Most baby cribs come in the standard rectangular shape. In this regard, the baby crib can be either a mini crib or a standard one. As a result, most crib mattresses are designed for either standard or mini-shape cribs.
But there are also cribs in other shapes such as ovals and circles. Most of these cribs come with their own specially designed mattresses. A small percentage of those cribs don’t include a mattress, which can be an issue because many stores don’t sell anything but mattresses for rectangular cribs.
14. How About a Second-Hand Crib Mattress?
This is a bad idea by default. There is no point in risking your little one’s safety and well-being just because you can save a few bucks. Plus, it is hard to determine how much it was used by its previous owner, or maybe that it had an owner before him/her. For that reason, it is a big no when it comes to buying a second-hand crib mattress.
15. Natural Fiber Mattress
The core of natural fiber mattresses is coconut fiber featuring a set of other materials. Thanks to their properties, the air can circulate freely through the mattress. Plus, they are coated with latex for extra protection and strength.
These mattresses are one of the firmest, last quite long, and can hold their shape quite well.
16. Buying a Hypoallergenic Mattress
If asthma and allergies are an issue within your family, then it is advisable to consider choosing a hypoallergenic mattress. Hypoallergenic mattresses come with a top layer that can be easily removed and machine washed at 60°. That way, all the dust particles responsible for the allergies are destroyed.
Their greatest advantage over other mattresses is that they are easy to clean, and are a great choice if the little one has asthma or some other allergy.
On the other hand, they tend to cost a lot more than the other types of mattresses.
Hopefully, we have de-mystified the process of buying an excellent crib mattress. People who are dealing with this challenging task for the first time, as well as people that choose poorly once, will benefit most from this mini-guide.
All they need to do is to remember the key points here and apply them when it comes time to choose. Other than that, to be persistent in their search and listen to their reasoning.