10 Best Baking Mats Reviews and Buying Guide
Table of Contents
How to Choose a Baking Mat?
Earlier, to bake cookies in an oven or pan, users had to use a lot of oil, ghee or butter for greasing to make sure that the cookie dough does not stick to the surface of the baking pan in the baking process.
Thanks to the baking mats! They are great innovations that help people to bake cookies without using unhealthy greasing substances. Above all, they come in different materials and colors along with size variants to help users in many ways.
Baking mats are designed for creating a non-stick and an even surface on standard baking sheets. They help users with making cookies that are not burnt at bottoms and do not stick to the pan.
Most users feel that these mats stay long if they are hand-washed as against dishwasher washing. Also, some suggest not to cut cookies directly on the mat.
The reason is that the knife used for cutting will destroy the non-stick surface of the baking mat. As against lining the sheet pan with foil, cooks can use the baking mat for cooking savory foods like chicken breasts and baked salmon.
5 Benefits of Baking Mats
- They can be used again and again several times.
- Baking mats can do almost any work done by a parchment
- They can improve the taste and flavor of your cookies as against traditional baking sheets
- They will help with keep your workstation organized
- Many mats come with measure marking or template that will help first-timers to learn.
Now, you know that your decision of buying a baking mat is good. But, you will be interested in understanding the points to consider in shopping for these mats.
Quick Summary
1. Best for Baking – GRIDMANN Baking Mat
2. Best Baking Mat with Measurement – Non-slip Silicone Pastry Mat
3. Best Set – Amazon Basics Silicone Baking Mat
4. Best Design – Kitzini Silicone Baking Mat
5. Best Affordable Baking Mat – Last Confection Silicone Baking Mat
6. Best durable – Silpat Premium Baking Mat
7. Best temperature Friendly Baking Mat – HOTPOP Silicone Baking Mat
8. Best Non-stick – STATINT Silicone Baking Mat
9. Easiest to Clean – Zulay Kitchen Baking Mat
10. Best overall Baking mat – LIMNUO Silicone baking mat
Top Rated Baking Mats
1. Best for Baking – GRIDMANN Baking Mat
Baking mats are not only great for baking, they usually offer so much more. They come in different sizes, depending on preference. The GRIDMANN Baking Mat offers so many features that make it the baker’s favorite.
This baking mat features a durable and excellent half-sheet design, coming in a two-pack set. You do not need grease, fattening oils or parchment paper in your baking pan anymore with this non-stick surface baking mat. It ensures your goods are well baked as it can withstand temperatures up to 480 degrees in the oven. You can be sure your food items will be evenly cooked in the oven with this baking mat. Worry no more about burned or undercooked spots.
With its reusable quality, you get to save money by using it over and over again. Unlike baking sheets or some pans that scratch easily, this silicone baking mat is resilient to scratches and wear caused by utensils. It is very easy to clean after use; all you need is to wipe it with soap and water. Also, it is dishwasher safe.
2. Best Baking Mat with Measurement – Non-slip Silicone Pastry Mat
When you need space, convenience, and quality all in one place, this Silicone Baking mat is an excellent choice. Its many amazing features will make baking a walk in the park for you.
Featuring surface measurement of 24 x 16 inches, which is enough kneading or rolling space. It has several markings on its surface. These markings are designed to help you make the perfect pie or pizza shape. The markings vary in size, so you can bake pie or pizza of various sizes depending on what is needed. Keep your dough steady on this mat without the risk of it slipping off the table. Due to its double thickness, this baking mat adheres strongly to the countertop.
This mat is reinforced with fiberglass, making it very durable. Use it as many times a possible. You do not have to worry about the dough sticking to its surface as it is non-stick. Clean this mat easily with warm water and soap. It is also dishwasher safe. It comes with a 12-months warranty, guaranteeing the quality of this product.
3. Best Set – Amazon Basics Silicone Baking Mat
Amazon Basics offers various products in different niches. When it comes to baking, it offers this affordable and durable baking mat.
It offers a set of 2 non-stick baking mats. They both measure 11.6 x 16.5 inches. This size fits perfectly for half-sheet pans. You can bake, roast, or prep food on the food-safe baking mat. It supports temperatures up to 480°F, evenly cooking the food in the process.
4. Best Design – Kitzini Silicone Baking Mat
This Kitzini Silicone baking mat is one that every home deserves. It comes in a pack of 3, each half sheet.
Use this non-stick baking mat for any type of baking. It is an excellent replacement for disposable parchment papers. Say goodbye to grease and oil. With this baking mat, you can bake confidently without needing to worry about your baking pan getting burnt. This mat can be placed in baking pans and can withstand temperatures ranging from -400C – 4800C. It evenly distributes heat during baking, eliminating soggy bottoms or undercooked spots.
They are eco-friendly, reusable, and easy to clean. Each baking sheet guarantees the usage of up 3,000 times before showing signs of aging. With just warm soapy water, you can easily clean these baking mats. They are also dishwasher safe.
5. Best Affordable Baking Mat – Last Confection Silicone Baking Mat
Here is another quality baking mat fit for all baking purposes. This mat has a lot to offer to both novice and seasoned pastry chefs alike.
This silicone baking mat will make baking a whole lot easier for you. It includes a set of two baking pans, each one with a dimension of 8-1/2” x 11-1/2”. Make any of your quarter-sheet pans non-sticky with this mat. This mat eliminates your need for grease, spray, and even parchment paper while baking. It is oven safe and can withstand a temperature of up to 4800F during baking. You can also use it for roasting or broiling.
Last confection ensured these eco-friendly baking mats are reusable for a long time. Apart from keeping your kitchen countertop clean and your pans burnt free, these mats are easy to maintain. All you need to clean them is soap and water.
6. Best durable – Silpat Premium Baking Mat
Another great choice of baking mat is the Silpat Premium Baking Mat. It has stood the test of time and is very popular among chefs around the world.
Featuring a French design and measuring 11-⅝” x 16-½”. You can easily fit this in a 13″ x 18″ baking pan. It features excellent quality make of fiberglass mesh that makes it durable. With this mat, you can make your baking pans non-sticky. Eliminating the need for parchment paper, grease, and oil sprays. This also makes cleaning your pans quite easy, ensuring food items do not get burnt in them.
It is food, oven, and freezer safe. Made to consistently bake your dough at a temperature up to 480 degrees F. It can withstand freezing temperature as low as -40 degrees F. Cleaning this mat is quite easy as it is dishwasher safe.
7. Best temperature Friendly Baking Mat – HOTPOP Silicone Baking Mat
Take your baking skills to the next level with this colorful and durable baking mat from HOTPOP. It comes in various sizes colors so you can choose based on your preference.
This particular product comes with 2 half sheets measuring 16.5 x 11.6 inches and 2 quarter sheets each measuring 11.5 x 8.5. Waste no more parchment paper and rid yourself of messy sprays, grease, or butter with this non-stick baking mat. Cook, prep and bake healthy meals on the HOTPOP baking mat. From pie to bread or macaroni, this mat can work for you.
It ensures the even distribution of heat while baking and eliminates the risk of having soggy spots in your baked food. This mat can withstand hot temperatures as high as 480°F and can also be used for freezing food items to temperatures as low as -40°F. You can get a full refund if you are not satisfied with this product.
8. Best Non-stick – STATINT Silicone Baking Mat
Baking is made easy with the STATINT Silicone Baking Mat. Made with quality materials suitable for kneading, rolling dough, and also baking foods. You can prep pizza dough for your guests on this baking mat.
It features a fiberglass and Silicone design, made to withstand heat as high as 446°F. The non-stick surface eliminates the need for lubricants like butter, fats, oil, or sprays. Bake any sort of food on this mat with the assurance of a quality turnout. You get to use this product over and over again. Cleaning it is also very easy. Wipe with warm soapy water or clean in the dishwasher (top rack).
9. Easiest to Clean – Zulay Kitchen Baking Mat
Do not be deceived by its simple look, this baking mat will make your baking experience a whole lot easier.
Save extra money on baking by removing parchment paper, non-stick sprays, and foil from your list. You would not be needing them with this non-stick baking mat. It ensures heat is distributed evenly during baking and is able to withstand temperatures up to 400°F. Storage is easy, all you need is to roll it up. When it comes to cleaning, you only need warm soapy water and a washcloth. You can also wash this mat in the dishwasher.
Get a lifetime guarantee with this product. Quality is assured.
10. Best overall Baking mat – LIMNUO Silicone baking mat
Saving the best for the last. This product has all the features and qualities that belong to an excellent baking mat. It is the true baker’s friend.
It features a size of 16 x 20 inches. A food-safe mat that provides a non-stick platform for baking, roasting, or prepping food. It is made of reinforced fiberglass guaranteeing its durability. This baking mat will stay in your kitchen for a long long while, never tarnishing. It has mold sizes for making perfectly round pizzas or pies. You can also use it for shaping bread etc.
Never worry about your dough slipping to the floor with this baking mat anti-slip feature. It adheres strongly to your kitchen countertop. Cleaning this mat is quite easy, with clean water and soap.
8 Factors to Consider When Choosing Baking Mats
1. Size
As mentioned earlier, baking mats come in different sizes. To decide on the right size to buy, you should consider the type of baking pan you use frequently. You should make sure that you shop for the one that fits as snug as possible to the baking pan or to your cookie sheet. Ensure that the size of the mat is such that it does not either curl up or go beyond the tip of the baking pan.
Even, you will come across some mats that are specially designed for the users to customize the size as per their pan size by cutting the mat. You can go for such a mat if you cannot decide on the right size.
However, some mats should not be cut like the ones with a woven pattern that contains fiberglass. The reason is that if cut, the bits of fiberglass can fuse into the foods that you bake.
If you use more than one pan for baking, you can consider two baking mats to fit those baking pans.
If you have a standard home oven, the size of the baking mat ideal for your oven will be 13″ x 18″. The other options you will come across are medium size and small size at 9″ x 13″ and 6.5″ x 9″ respectively.
2. Consider the Material
Also, when you compare baking mats, you will come across models made out of different materials. You will come across mats made out of aluminum, steel, and the other alternative when it comes to the material is silicone.
Here, aluminum baking mats are undoubtedly an excellent material for baking. The reason is that it is a good conductor of heat. It means that it will help with even baking. Also, it will not rust and it is durable as well. However, you should remember that the shiny surface of the aluminum baking mat can prevent proper browning.
Not just aluminum, steel is also an ultimate conductor of heat and will help with even baking. Further, steel baking mats will be aesthetically appealing. Above all, the high strength and sustainability feature of this material makes it one of the best innovations.
Nowadays, most users feel that silicon baking mats are beneficial to others. The reason is that they are easy to clean and they are good for kneading dough on. Also, the chances of browning and burning are very less in these mats when compared to metal-based sheets. Even baking of foods will happen when you use silicone baking mats. It means that all parts of the dish will be equally cooked in this alternative as against others.
When comparing the above-mentioned three materials, most users these days go for silicon mats as they are newer entrants and they are efficiently created as compared to conventional variants that are being used for long.
3. Essential Features
You might think that all baking mats are similar and they do not differ. But, certain features can make some baking sheets better than others. For instance, you can consider the sheets with the following features:
- Non-stick: To ease your job, non-stick baking mats can be the best choice than a sheet without this feature.
- Dishwasher safe: As mentioned earlier, people feel that stay long when they are hand-washed. The reason is that they might be using a mat that is not dishwasher-friendly. Nowadays, you can find dishwasher-friendly variants that will ensure that you can easily wash the mat after every use or as per the product instructions.
- PFOA Free: PFOA denotes Acid. It is a chemical used in making PTFE. The most-known example is Teflon. Just to make sure that the mat remains non-stick, some manufacturers use Teflon coating. But, when you go for a mat with PFOA-free coating, you can make sure that it will safe for your health.
- PTFE Free: This is yet another chemical used for the creation of non-stick coatings and as polytetrafluoroethylene. When you find that a product is PTFE-free, it means that it is produced without the use of PFOA.
- Set: When you go for mats that come as sets, you can save on the shopping. For instance, when you buy the mats in the set, you can continue to use the one when you have added another sheet to the dishwasher for washing. So, units coming in a set can be a feature to consider.
- Lid-included: Some sheets come with a lid. It means that you will have the base pan, along with the sheet over which you can place the lid that comes along for even baking.
Considering the features listed above, do not forget to consider the mats with better customer ratings. Even, the mats come in different colors and if you are particular about the attractiveness of the baking mats, you can consider colored variants.
4. How Flexible is the Mat?
When you find the mat is rigid, it will be hard to handle. So, before you shop for any mat check whether it is flexible enough. This type of flexibility will also help with easy storage after use and even it will help with easy washing of the baking mat.
5. Consider the Level of Heat Resistance
Some baking mats are designed to withstand higher heat, while some are designed to withstand just a certain degree of heat. The more heat resistance a product has, the better you can stay confident that there will not be any harm to the mat just in case the heat increases suddenly due to one reason or another.
6. Oven, Freezer and Microwave Safety
Of course, you know that the baking mat should be oven safe. But, you should not forget to check whether the manufacturer has specified the mat to be freezer and microwave safe.
Sometimes, rather than the regular oven, you might be baking in a microwave, and in these instances, this feature will help. Further, some baked items should be kept in the freezer for a few hours to come to the form. Every time, you cannot remove the baked food from the mat before placing it in the freezer. In these situations, the freezer safety of the mat will help.
7. Consider the Weight
You might think that baking mats generally weigh low. But, to make sure that it is actually low do not forget to look at the product specification for weight details. Even, the specification page will show you details about the dimension of the mat so that you can make an informed decision in shopping for the right baking mat.
8. Life and Durability
As compared to traditional parchment papers, silicone baking mats are known for better durability and life. However, before you choose any mat, it would be wise to give appropriate attention to the life expectancy of the mat. Ensure that the mat will be safe to use and the manufacturer has assured a better lifespan.
Wrapping It Up
Every kitchen deserves a baking mat. However, they are available in different sizes and qualities. You want to get a baking mat you can trust is food safe and can last you a long while. Other features to look out for are size and heat tolerance.
If you love being precise when baking, check out Non-slip Silicone Pastry Mat. The best affordable baking mat is the Last Confection Silicone Baking Mat and for the Best Overall Baking mat, we have the LIMNUO Silicone baking mat.
Baking is part of many of our lives. So, if you are looking for healthy and easy baking, you can consider buying the right baking mat. The considerations discussed above will help you with the right selection.
Rate This Article
