10 Best Cookie Cutters Reviews and Buying Guide
Table of Contents
What are Cookie Cutters?
We are not the new generation tasting Christmas cookies. Our ancestors have been enjoying them for hundreds of years. There are many mentions of sweet cookies enjoyed during vacation dating back to the medieval period.
They were first identified to be used in Europe and they came to the United States early as the 17th century. The movement happened with English and Dutch Colonists traveling to the United States.
A cookie cutter is actually an American Term and British people call it a biscuit cutter. As the name implies, it is a tool used for cutting cookies from the cookie dough in the desired shape and size.
Benefits of Cookie Cutters
If you are thinking about whether or not to buy cookie cutters, you should understand that you might have been using the same round-shaped object for cutting cookies for long. Even, you might have been making shapes using knives. But, with cookie cutters in different shapes, you can excite your kids and family, who always expect innovation in cooking. A cookie cutter will have sharp edges to make sure that users can easily cut off the cookie dough in the desired shape before the baking process.
Quick Summary
- Best Overall – Wilton Animal Cookie Cutter Set
- Best Stainless Steel – HULISEN Cookies Cutters
- Best Budget – YXCLIFE MINI Metal Cookie Cutters Set
- Best for Holiday– O-Kinee Piece Christmas Cookie Cutter
- Best for Christmas – LEEFE Christmas Cookie Cutter
- Best Cutter for Kids – New Dinosaur Cookie Cutter Set
- Most Durable – StarPack Home Christmas Cookie Cutters Set
- Best Cutter For Beginners – TAOUNOA Cookie Cutters
- Best Cutters For Professionals – Hibery Christmas Cookie Cutters
- Best For Baking – WADNGXM Christmas Cookie Cutter Set
Top Pick Cookie Cutters Reviews
1. Best Overall – Wilton Animal Cookie Cutter Set
If you are planning on making some delicious cookies, here’s one cutter you should get. The Wilton Animal cookie cutter comes in very fascinating shapes so you can make cookies from a variety of animal shapes. It is the perfect cookie cutter for the holidays and your kiddie’s parties. You can make nice chocolate chip cookies of them and as you know kids love animals. With the Wilton cutter, you can easily out fun shapes for your coloring icings for decorating your snacks. These cutters cone in different colors which makes it even more fun if you are doing DIY cookies with your kids.
It’s easy working with these cutters and you don’t need to be an expert baker to use these Wilton cookie cutters. They are great for everyday use and you can make as many cookies as you want. The Wilton cookie cutters come in a set of 50 which is a lot. They are durable and great for everyday use.
2. Best Stainless Steel – HULISEN Cookies Cutters Set
HULISEN is one reputable brand you can trust to deliver not only the best but also quality kitchen essentials. These cookie cutters by Hulisen come in a set of five different shapes cutters for your baking. You can use it to make different sizes of biscuits and cookies. It serves your baking needs and comes in a set fit-all design. This way you can make very nice cookies, donuts, flaky biscuits, mini cakes and many more. The stainless steel cutters are durable and very easy to clean. It is also dishwasher safe and does not corrode. These cookie cutters are one of the best quality baking tools you will need to make all kinds of desserts. Also, you will find it easy to use this baking tool as it comes with an ergonomic handle.
3. Best Budget – YXCLIFE MINI Metal Cookie Cutters Set
This YXClife cookie cutter is another quality stainless steel tool you should consider getting. The mini cutter comes in a set of 24. It has 8 different shapes of cutters which include 3 each of different sizes. The shapes younger include a heart, flower, circle, rectangular, oval, square, and triangular shapes. It is an everyday use baking tool so you can make your cookies anytime. These cookie cutters are perfect for your biscuits, fruit bouquets, chocolates, fondant cakes, and other desserts.
4. Best for Holiday – O-Kinee Piece Christmas Cookie Cutter
The O-Kinee cookie cutter comes in a set of 25 and it includes a variety of Christmas shapes. You can make your cookies in the shape of a Christmas tree, gingerbread boy, a snowman, or even a snowflake. This cutter fits perfectly in the Christmas season especially if you have to share lots of cookies around your neighborhood or if you plan on hosting a Christmas party. The O-Kinee cookie cutters are made from food-safe 304 stainless steel which is that resistant and long-lasting. You can also clean in your dishwasher and it has carefully polished biscuit mold so it won’t be difficult getting your biscuit out.
Apart from your cookie dough, you can use this cutter for many other purposes. You can use it for your bread, cheese, sandwiches, soft fruits, pancakes, and even soap. You can use the O-Kinee cookie cutter to make Christmas-themed cookies for your friends and families.
5. Best Christmas Cutter – LEEFE Christmas Cookie Cutter
This is also another Christmas-themed cookie cutter you can get. The Leefee cutter comes in a set of fantastic shapes. It has 5 pieces which include a Christmas tree, snowman, reindeer, and gingerbread boy. This set of cutters is made from the finest quality stainless steel and is very easy to maintain. The design comes with folded edges which makes it very easy to hold. You can use it to make your brownies, sandwiches, pancakes, fruits, and other food. You can also use it for crafts especially for your kids to make their DIY projects. This cookie cutter set is durable and you will find it handy when you are planning a Christmas-themed party.
6. Best Cutter for Kids – New Dinosaur Cookie Cutter Set
If you are all about safe cooking, then you may want to look at this New Dinosaur cookie cutter set. It comes made with certified food grade stainless and the best part is you can use it for food at a temperature from 40°F to 230°F. It is durable and won’t rust even when you wash it with water. This cookie cutter comes in a set of 7 which comprises dinosaurs. You will find a tyrannosaurus, pterodactyl, brontosaur, triceratops, spinosaurus, the head, and footprint of a dinosaur. If your kids are fans of the movie Jurassic Park or love dinosaurs, you should make them cookies with these dinosaur cookie cutters.
7. Best Durable – StarPack Home Christmas Cookie Cutters Set
Christmas is a time to share with family and you can do that over freshly baked cookies. You will also want to include these StarPack cutters among your baking essentials for Christmas. You can use these cutters to make those beautiful holiday cookies you have always admired on Pinterest. The stainless steel design is food safe and you won’t have to worry about safety. It comes with folded edges so your cookie dough doesn’t get stuck. You can make as many cookies as you desire with this cutter. The StarPack cutters come in a set of 8 comprising of Christmas-themed shapes like snowflakes, angels, reindeer, Christmas bells, snowman, Christmas tree, gingerbread boy, candy cane, and Christmas stocking. The durable stainless steel design is long-lasting and easy to clean.
8. Best Cutter for Beginners – TAOUNOA Cookie Cutters
These Taounoa cutters will give you the perfect creative idea for your Christmas baking. These cookie cutters are one of the best especially when you consider things like durability, ease of use, and safety. You can make fun cookies with this tool and it is perfect for beginners. You can use it for your Christmas party baking and it is versatile so you can use it for your Christmas decorations.
The Taounoa cutters are safe and you can always reuse them. It is non-stick so it won’t be difficult getting your cookie dough out. The cutter comes in 26 different shapes so you can make lots of cookies. You can get your kids involved with baking with these cutters as they are safe. The best part is you can use it for any occasion whether Christmas, birthday parties and others.
9. Best Cutters for Professionals – Hibery Christmas Cookie Cutters
Hibery makes high-quality bakewares and this cookie cutter is no exception. They are made from the best quality stainless steel and are durable. The edges of the cutters are folded which makes it easy to work with using your hands. These Christmas-themed cookie cutters become in a variety is g shapes and sizes. All of the shapes depict Christmas so if you want to set up a Christmas party, you will be needing these cutters. They are also very easy to clean and are dishwasher safe. The cutters come in a set of 15 and you can use them for multiple purposes apart from just making cookies. The Hibery cutters can be used for your soft fruits, sandwiches, cheese, bread, pancake, and many other foods.
10. Best Cutters for Baking – WADNGXM Christmas Cookie Cutter Set
These 5 set cutters from Wadngxm are another Christmas-themed baking tool you get today. The high-quality stainless steel cutter is not only affordable but long-lasting. If you need to make cookies for Christmas, your kids will find the gingerbread boy, snowflakes, candy cane, Christmas tree, and snowman fascinating. The quality of the stainless steel is exceptional and it is certified food safe. It is designed with a perfect baking mold that won’t make your cookies get stuck. You can also get these cutters and have your kids join you to make delicious Christmas cookies. The design is safe, so you don’t need to worry about their safety.
10 Factors to Consider When Buying Cookie Cutters
Irrespective of whether you buy a single cookie cutter or even if you buy them in sets, you will have to consider different factors to ensure that you will end up with the right cutter for your cookie-making requirements:
1. For What Occasion You Need Cookie Cutters?
Cookie cutters designed for different occasions can be bought. For instance, if you plan to buy them for Christmas, you can find them in suitable shapes like Christmas trees, Santa, and similar choices.
On the other hand, if you plan to buy them for making cookies for your child’s birthday, you will find them in the appropriate design.
Of course, a cookie cutter that you purchase for this Christmas can be used next year as well. Even, you can make cookies in Christmas-related shapes all year round as well.
2. Material
The material used in making a cookie cutter is an essential factor to consider. As you are planning to use the cutter for preparing a dish, you should ensure that cutters made out of safe materials are chosen.
Some of the options you will come across are wood, fabric, silicone, stainless steel, plastic, and metal. Here are the benefits of each of these materials:
- Wood cookie cutters will last longer. However, you should be careful about preserving them as they are prone to pest infestation.
- Fabric cookie cutters are easy to wash after every use. But, you should consider whether the edges are sharp to ensure easy cutting.
- Silicon cutters are easy to clean and so maintenance will be easier.
- Plastic cutters are affordable. But, check whether food-safe plastic has been used for its making.
- Not just stainless steel, but also other metal-based cutters are the most preferred choices. The reason is that they have sharp edges for ensuring easy cookie cutting.
3. Features to Consider
You might be wondering whether there will be any special features in cookie cutters. But, some features will enhance the easiness of use of these cutters. Here are some features to consider when you shop for these cutters:
- Non-stick Surface
With this feature, you can ensure that you can get the cookies in the right and desired shape without the dough getting caught in the cutter. making your job easier, this feature will also make your end product look at its best.
So, consider a cookie cutter with this feature. When you go for a cutter with a non-stick surface, you need not have to dip the cutter in sugar or flour before use.
- Dishwasher Safe
If you are a who will be frequently using the cookie cutter for making cookies in different shapes, you should consider whether the cutter is dishwasher safe.
This feature will ensure that you can get the cutters cleaned with ease after every use as against washing them using your hands.
- Organizing
If you buy a set of cutters in different shapes, the set should provide you the opportunity to easily keep the cutters organized after every use. As you can store every cutter in the box or pouch in which the set comes, you can ensure easy and safe organizing of the cutters without losing a single piece of the cutter.
This is an essential feature as cookie cutters are smaller tools that can be easily misplaced.
4. Cutters with a Handle
You might be wondering whether it will be possible to find cutters with a handle. You are right. Mostly, we come across cutters available in different shapes along without any handle. But, to help commercial bakers, who will have to handle huge quantities of cookie cutting tasks every time, to make their work easier, these cutters are available with handles as well for easy handling.
With regular cutters, you will not have the option to work without touching the dough. But, with handles, physical contact with the dough can be avoided. So, you can consider this as an option if you feel that a cookie-cutter with a handle is essential for you.
5. Colorful Choices
If you wish that the cutters should be available in different colors in your home, you should not go for the regular metal cutters. The reason is that the set of metal cutters will have cutters in silver color as common.
But, when you opt for other materials like plastic and silicone, you will find them in multiple colors.
Of course, color is not going to make any difference in the shape and size of your cookies. But, they will look attractive on your countertop when you are engaged in the cookie cutting process.
6. Consider the Types
When you compare cookie cutters, you will find them in different types. Here are some details to know in this regard to help you with the right selection:
- Cutout Cutters
Cutouts are regular cutters that we come across. They will be available in different materials and they are the simplest of all types. When you use this cutter, you will have to just press the cutter into the cookie dough that you have already rolled flat for producing the shape of the outline of the cutter.
- Detail Imprints
In some cookies that you shop from stores, you would have found some detailing within the cookies. This is possible with this cookie cutter. It is very much similar to the cutout type when it comes to usage. The only difference is that there will be details in the cookies prepared using this type of cutter. This type is commonly made using metal and plastic materials.
- Cookie Mold
In this type, the mold will have ornamental designs on the surface. Once the dough is prepared, the mold is pressed into the dough for producing not just the expected cut, but also the cut will have an embossed design. These molds will either be in the shape of a rolling pin or the shape of flat disks.
- Cookie Press Cutters
Otherwise called cookie gun, for making large batches of cookies at a faster pace. In this type, the cookie dough is extruded to the baking sheet in different shapes. Otherwise, these designs are hard to achieve by hand.
7. Durability
As you know, you will be interested in ensuring that the cutter will stay with you for long. Some cutters will have sharp edges initially. But, after some time of use, they will become blunt, thereby making the cutter unusable.
So, durability and the quality of material used in making the cutters are essential considerations. Only then, you can use the cutters for a longer period without replacement.
8. Consider the Size
Some people think about making small size cookies, while some wish that they should get medium-sized cookies. Even, some people wish to make cookies in the standard size that we come across in the market. Based on your requirement, you should decide whether you should choose small, medium, or standard size cookie cutters.
9. Personal VS Commercial Use
You should first decide whether you are going to use the cutters to prepare cookies for your family and friends or you plan to sell the homemade cookies.
To help with this, cookie cutters are classified under two major categories and they are commercial purposes and at-home hobbyists. So, decide on your choice accordingly.
10. Ease of Use
When it comes to the easiness of use, not just the size counts, but even you should consider the strength and flexibility aspects. It should not be heavyweight to handle and easiness to wash is also essential.
Wrapping It Up
Now that you know the best cookie cutters in the market today, why not hurry to get yours now. Cookie cutters are a must-have for your kitchen and you may want to consider one especially for holidays and parties.
We recommend the Wilton Animal Cookie Cutter which is great for everyday use and your kids will be fascinated by the animal shapes. The HULISEN Cookies Cutters Set is made from the finest certified quality stainless steel and it won’t rust even when you wash it with water. If you want to get value for your money, you may want to consider the 24 set YXCLIFE MINI Metal Cookie Cutters, they are versatile and you can serve all your baking needs.
With the best cookie cutters, you can excite your family with the best cookies for different occasions and even for regular day-to-day use. Consider the points mentioned above and make the best shopping.
Rate This Article
