Top 10 Best Gelato Makers Reviews and Buying Guide
Table of Contents
Gelato makers are machines widely used to make frozen desserts, especially the Italian version of ice cream, gelato. The gelato maker churns and freezes the pre-made gelato mixture poured into it. The gelato comes out of the machine ready to eat.
It takes several minutes to prepare fresh homemade gelato using a gelato maker. These machines save a significant amount of time, money, and effort. As they are relatively compact, less technically complicated, and easy to operate, users find them handy.
1. Cuisinart ICE-70P1 Stainless Steel Gelato Maker
This gelato maker comes with both automatic and manual modes. The automatic or pre-set mode is excellent; you can put the ingredients in the machine and leave it altogether. The manual mode has a built-in timer, which starts the countdown once the churning process starts.
Although it is possible to operate the machine for up to 30 minutes, it only takes less than twenty minutes to make a batch of gelato. There is a convenient alert option on the device, which lets you alert every other five minutes to keep up with the texture of the gelato mixture. One downside is that the machine felt noisy while operating. The texture of the output gelato is quite fluffy and impressive.
- There is a spacious opening to add ingredients conveniently
- Built-in LCD screen
- Two quarts capacity
- Multiple speed settings
- Auto shut-off feature
- The freezer bowl is relatively heavy
- It takes more than 24 hours to freeze the bowl completely
2. Nostalgia 6 Quarts Electric Gelato Maker
This gelato maker features a different user interface than a regular gelato maker bowl. While most gelato makers demand that the bowl be frozen ten to twelve hours before the gelato-making process, this gelato maker can make instant gelato without freezing any part.
It has a barrel-like design. While this design with no additional attachments or complicated parts makes it reasonably simple to use, storage tends to be tricky. Even though all parts of this gelato maker fit right into the barrel alias bucket, as the size of it is relatively large, it does not fit into a regular-sized cupboard.
- 6 quarts capacity
- The design includes an easy-carry handle
- Supports multiple gelato flavors
- The lids are see-through to promote better monitoring
- Relatively loud
- Storage and cleaning are difficult
3. Ninja NC301 CREAMi One Touch Gelato Maker
This is a compact yet sturdy built gelato maker. It is simple to use. It comes with freezer-friendly storage cups. It would help if you froze the gelato maker bowl about 24 hours before the preparation. Once the preparation starts, it takes roughly three to four minutes to make a smooth gelato.
It comes with three different bowls and a recipe book with over thirty gelato maker-compatible recipes. It is a compact unit; thus, storage would be fine. Planning the preparation and keeping the bowl in the freezer on the previous day could be a letdown.
- Seven one-touch pre-set programs
- It comes with three containers and their lids
- The easy user interface makes it even more suitable for use by children
- Innovative Creamerizer System
- Relatively expensive
4. Elite Gourmet EIM 1400M Americana Electric Gelato Maker
This is an easy-to-use electric gelato maker. The control panel is quite simple and easy to understand. You have to freeze the bowl before the preparation process, and once done, you can make the gelato instantly.
The recipe book that comes along comes in handy, especially if you are a beginner. The see-through lid on the bowl prevents any splashing during the gelato churning and lets the user peek through it during the preparation.
- 1.5 quarts capacity
- A chute opening to add the ingredients
- Convenient on/off switch
- No salt needed
- Relatively lower capacity
- Has to freeze the bowl prior
5. HAIMMY Automatic Electric Gelato Maker
This is an electric gelato maker which is capable of freezing itself. This self-freezing technology offers great convenience as it eliminates the need to freeze the bowl. You can add the ingredients for making the gelato to this machine, and it freezes and churns for around 1.5 hours and provide you with perfectly textured gelato.
Another convenient feature is that, even after the churning process is over and the gelato is prepared, the machine retains the cool for around four hours so that the gelato remains fresh and cool. This feature is great as it eliminates the need to remove the gelato immediately from the machine and store it in the refrigerator for later usage.
- No prior freezing needed
- Keep Cool function for up to four hours
- Automatic operation
- Soft and hard modes
- 700 ml capacity
- Capacity is not ideal for bigger families
6. UKKISO Portable Automatic Gelato Maker
This automatic gelato maker removes the need to oversee the gelato-making process manually. The built-in LCD screen displays all the vitals during the churning process; thus, you can remain worry-free. It is lightweight and, therefore, highly portable.
You need not freeze the bowls prior as it has a built-in compressor capable of self-freezing. The Keep Cool function is an excellent advantage as it helps you keep the prepared gelato within the machine without losing its cool. The mixing bowl is easy to remove and, therefore, easy to clean.
- BPA-free material
- Capable of making instant gelato
- Timer control
- It comes with a compatible spoon
- The 1.2 quarts capacity mostly suits individual needs
7. INTASTING Stainless Steel Gelato Maker
This is a high-performance gelato maker. It is very sleek and compact in design and suits every kitchen. Except for the need to priorly freeze the bowl, the device is excellent for preparing gelato with remarkable consistency. It only takes roughly twenty minutes to churn and prepare the gelato.
The texture of the gelato is incredibly smooth and fluffy, thanks to the high-performing motor. The stirring motion is highly uniform and even; thus, the gelato has no inconsistent portions or pieces of ice.
- 1.6 quarts capacity
- Food-grade aluminum material
- It comes with an anti-splashing and see-through lid
- Even stirring for greater texture
- 24 months warranty
- The bowl has to be frozen twelve hours prior
8. Euro Cuisine 1.5 Quarts Gelato Maker
This automatic gelato maker comes with a 4-serving-compatible cup. It only takes less than thirty minutes to finish the gelato-making process. The bowl is freezable and double-insulated, efficiently retaining the cold temperature for a while after finishing the preparation.
The mixing paddle is relatively easy to remove and clean. It is a very suitable machine as it only expects you to add the ingredients and switch the device to initiate the preparation process. The bowl has a transparent lid, a safety lock, and a convenient pour spot.
- BPA-free material
- 1.5 quarts capacity
- Double-insulated bowl
- Ideal for making up to four servings of gelato
- The bowl has to be frozen on the previous day itself
9. JoyMech Compact Electric Gelato Maker
This is a compact and convenient gelato maker. The most significant advantage is that you don’t need to pre-freeze the bowl and add the ingredients to facilitate the preparation. It takes around 1.5 hours to make a smoothly textured gelato in this machine.
The device is also compatible with making drinks and beverages, which only take less than an hour. It is a lightweight device and, thus, is easy to carry around. An impressive feat of this gelato maker is that it is highly safe to be around as it does not involve any coolant or possible leakage.
- No pre-freezing necessary
- Semiconductor freezing
- Silent operation
- Anti-leakage technology
- Built-in compressor
- The bowl is not removable; thus, cleaning is a bit difficult
- Smaller capacity than what the manufacturers claim
10. Cuisinart ICE-100 Gelato Maker
This gelato maker has a convenient built-in freezing system. Thus, you need not pre-freeze the bowl to make gelato. It has a stainless-steel and plastic body with a contemporary design that suits any modern kitchen. It is relatively easy to move around.
The built-in touchpad control is very convenient and intuitive. This device has a countdown timer that helps you follow up on the preparation status. It only takes less than an hour to make gelato.
- Automatic operation
- Keep Cool function
- Blue LCD screen
- Ergonomic design
- Only 800 ml capacity
How to Choose the Best Gelato Maker?
Several top features to look into while purchasing a gelato maker are as follows.
There are two most common types of gelato makers; freezer bowl type and compressor type. The freezer bowl type demands that the freezing bowl be kept in the refrigerator a day before the actual preparation process. It needs the user to plan the process, but besides that downside, it is easy to use. The compressor type has a built-in compressor, which eliminates any prior freezing. This saves time and suits instant gelato-making needs. But they are relatively more expensive than their freezer bowl counterparts.
Capacity is a significant feature to look for in a gelato maker. A reasonable capacity allows the customer to use the machine to make different quantities. Usually, 1.5 quarts to 2 quarts is the capacity of an average gelato maker. Anything with more than 2 quarts capacity would be more than enough for bigger families.
Time of preparation
Despite the time required for pre-freezing the bowl, the actual time taken for churning and preparing the gelato is crucial. It is always handy to have a gelato maker that can stir the product in less than an hour, preferably half an hour. As the gelato makers are available in limited size ranges, a high preparation time would make it difficult when a need for multiple batches occurs.
Although a lid may sound less important, that’s not the case with a gelato maker. The amount of air infused into the gelato mixture has a significant role in determining the end texture of the gelato. Extra air in the gelato would cause it to be denser than usual. So, keeping the mixing bowl appropriately sealed during the mixing process is essential so that no extra air gets through.
Paddles or mixers of the gelato maker have to be removable to ensure that they are appropriately cleaned. A difficult-to-remove paddle causes parts of the gelato to remain in the system, affecting the machine’s quality and durability. Also, the paddle has to move about uniformly to reduce the air content in the mixture.
A domestic gelato maker is a great money-saving gadget that helps you make fresh homemade gelato without having much cooking or technical knowledge. These easy-to-use machines make dessert making an effortless affair. Despite having numerous counterparts, the Cuisinart ICE-70P1 Stainless Steel Gelato Maker came at the top of our review list due to the incredible texture it produces, easy user interface, high capacity, multiple speed settings, and many more.